Methods and Materials
Data Collection
Data was collected across all five boroughs of NYC. This analysis focuses on red-tailed hawk nests monitored between 2020 and 2025, a period representing a robust and consistent dataset following formalization of the project. Red-tailed hawks were selected as the focus of this analysis due to a larger sample size within the data.
Nesting observations were contributed by NYC Parks staff and trained scientists. Once an active nest was located, monitors recorded site characteristics, nest support structure (human-made or natural), key breeding milestone dates, and estimates of chick and fledgling numbers using standardized, non-invasive observation protocols developed by our team.
Breeding milestones were determined based on observed adult behavior. Monitors recorded the incubation date as the first observation of an adult sitting in a nest. Hatch date was recorded when nestling care was first observed, such as adults returning to the nest with prey. Fledging was recorded upon observation of an eyas away from the nest, perched on a structure other than the direct nest support element, or upon indication of first flight. The dates are approximate.
Analysis
were analyzed, and results were compared between nests on human-made and natural support structures.
The ANS was used because exact dates for breeding milestones across all monitored nests, preclud the use of other estimation methods. Although ANS is known to positively bias estimates of reproductive success, we followed recommendations from Steenhof and Kochert (1982) by including only nests with known approximate incubation start dates and known final outcomes. This reduces bias associated with nests discovered later in the breeding season, which have a higher probability of success at this later stage.
Between 2020 and 2025, a total of 216 active red-tailed hawk nests were documented across NYC. Natural support structures were more common, accounting for 65% of nest site locations (Figure 1). Within the sample, 117 sites met criteria for inclusion in the nest longevity analysis (minimum incubation start date observed), with 32% sites on human-made support structures and 68% on natural support structures. ANS was calculated for 123 nests (those with both approximate incubation start dates and known outcomes) including 36% nest attempts on human-made support structures and 64% on natural support structures.
Figure 1.
Figure 1 Clip art image representing a tree. Top third of image is shaded gray to represent 35% of total nests found on human-made support structures. Lower two-thirds of image is shaded green to represent 65% of total nests found on natural support structures. Alt Text:
Do you have any conflicts of interest that could bias your ability to provide an independent review?
Alyssa Davidge
No.
Daniel Ludwig
No
Douglas W. Wacker
no
What did the authors do a good job with?
Alyssa Davidge
The author did a good job explaining the importance of investigating different nesting structures in a straightforward way. They also did well scaffolding their investigation with clear links between what they were measuring to explain the similarities/differences between nesting structures and why. They did a great job of taking already existing information and leveraging it for scientific research-taking care to outline the measures taken to prepare the data for analysis.
Daniel Ludwig
Presentation of a raptor becoming more urban and a major US city being sensitive to the species.
Douglas W. Wacker
The study focus was interesting and the use of citizen scientists laudable. The authors did well to emphasize that their results showing equivalent nest success on natural and man-made structures should (hopefully) inform hawk-friendly construction moving forward.
How do you think this research will contribute to the field?
Alyssa Davidge
This work will add to the call for more consideration for wildlife in the construction and maintenance of urban spaces. It will also provide a good launch point for more rigorous statistical analysis of effective measures for supporting urban raptors in the future. It has also set up a method for using community science to address scientific questions-which is an increasingly valuable resource in urban environments.
Daniel Ludwig
Spports an awareness to avian species adjusting to a changing landscape or a species using what is available for nest success. Now how do we provide that and if so how?
Douglas W. Wacker
This research suggests that red-tailed hawk nests on man-made structures in NYC, while used less frequently than natural support structures, lead to similar nest success. This can be used to advocate for future architectural design intentionally friendly to hawk nesting. The article also adds to a growing list of studies utilizing citizen science to address topics of conservation interest.
Regarding the study design and methods, what do the authors need to fix or improve upon to be fit for publication?
Alyssa Davidge
The study area needs to be more clearly defined either in writing or via a figure. A few more pertinent details about the location that might influence site-specific outcomes would be a good addition in the study area context. Besides apparent nesting success which has a reference associated with the practice, it would have been prudent to include some way of delineating man-made structure from “natural” structures-considering urban trees are often planted and manicured for specific outcomes in the urban environment not unlike the structures composed of building materials. This distinction should come with its own reference.
Daniel Ludwig
Delete the 3 Figures and wpok on Table tirles.
Douglas W. Wacker
The authors need to do a few things to make this paper ready for publication.1) They need to avoid saying that nest success was “slightly higher” for human-made supports in the abstract, as nest success values did not significantly differ by support structure type in this study. 2) They need to add the calculations for apparent nest success and nest longevity to the Methods (not just the Results).
Regarding the analysis and interpretation of their findings, what do the authors need to fix or improve upon to be fit for publication?
Alyssa Davidge
It is mentioned that the statistics the authors explored were not able to make meaningful distinctions between the effect size of a natural structure relative to a man-made structure on apparent nest success, but it would have been helpful for the authors to explain what statistical analyses they considered. Discussion of bias performs an essential function of stepping the reader through the design process and intent in the methods, but that should be decoupled from the approach a little more and the bias should be discussed in the discussion.
Daniel Ludwig
Please see my edits.
Douglas W. Wacker
It is critical for the authors to make the following changes prior to publication of their manuscript (most importantly, points 4, 5, 7, and 8).3) Replace the tree figure, as it is confusing since the grey section would not include trees, rather just man-made structures.4) In the Results, add measures of variation for nest longevity and ANS. If data are normally distributed with homogeneous variation across structure types, then means and standard errors are typical. If data are not normally distributed or there is heterogeneous data across structure types, then medians and interquartile ranges are typical.5) In the Results, include the statistical tests for the comparison of site longevity and ANS. If data are normal with homogenous variance, then t-tests are good. If data are not normal and/or have heterogenous variance across structure type groups, then Mann-Whitney U tests are good.6) Replace Table 1 with a Figure, either Figure 2 or a box-and-whiskers plot.7) Add variation (error bars, etc.) to Figure 3.8) In the Discussion, the authors need to include citations to the pre-existing scholarly literature. For example...The authors hypothesize that nests on human-made structures may be more successful in four ways. Is there evidence from other scholarly papers that human-made structures lead to greater nest longevity, reduced predator access, enhanced hunting opportunities, or greater structural stability for any other bird species? Is there evidence that human-made materials have a greater degree of storm protection than natural structures in other studies? That they provide greater structural stability than trees?Is there evidence in other studies that proximity to human activity is associated with reduced aerial predator predation? With fewer great-horned owls?Is there evidence in other studies that built environments offer clearer lines of sight than those in natural environments?
Is there anything else you think the authors need to fix in their article to be fit for publication?
Alyssa Davidge
Urban raptors listed are not an exhaustive accounting so the wording should be amended to “included but not limited to”.
Daniel Ludwig
Please see my edits.
Douglas W. Wacker
I’ve added comments to the manuscript itself, but the above list covers most of the required changes.
Do you have any concerns about the ethics of this research?
Alyssa Davidge
The research was conducted using available data and did not involve manipulation of the subjects. It also doesn’t make grand claims about the utility of the work. No, I have no concerns about the ethics of this work.
Daniel Ludwig
No.
Douglas W. Wacker
no